Massachusetts Supreme Court disapproves of prosecutorial rewards to witnesses
Two witnesses in Wayne Miranda's murder trial received $2000 each from the Chamber of Commerce because their testimony assisted in producing a guilty verdict. As the Boston Globe writes, the Massachusetts Supreme Court, while approving such witness reward programs generally, has ruled that prosecutors cannot participate in them or help witnesses get rewards when those rewards are contingent on convictions. Commonwealth v. Wayne Miranda, SJC-10568. From the Court's opinion:
We recognize that, to prove the crime charged, prosecutors often need to procure the cooperation and truthful information or testimony of reluctant witnesses. The interests of justice, however, are not well served when a witness's reward is contingent on the conviction of a defendant, rather than the provision of truthful information or testimony.
While the Massachusetts Supreme Court should be lauded for its ethical concern, its decision is somewhat ironic. Prosecutors routinely provide far greater benefits to criminal informant witnesses, in the form of liberty and leniency, than a few thousand dollars. In many jurisdictions, these rewards can be contigent on conviction. And even when the rewards are not expressly contingent on conviction, every attorney and informant knows that a witness in a successful conviction is more likely to get rewarded.
This is why Professor George Harris [author of Testimony for Sale: The Law and Ethics of Snitches and Experts, 28 Pepp. L. Rev. 1 (2000)], and I have recommended leveling the playing field by creating defense informants, i.e. rewards for informants who come forward with information that might help the defense rather than the prosecution. As it currently stands, an offender with information helpful to the defense cannot expect any benefits--only the government can give those. This lopsided arrangement is, as the Massachusetts Supreme Court pointed out, not in the interests of accuracy or justice.
Comments
I have a bad situation that I need feedback. I had a boyfriend that was in the drug game. My cousin who turned out to be a police C/Iset use up on several drug buys. She wore a wire twice and I am recorded talking to her. on all occasions she called me over 10 times begging me to come and called my boyfriend. I thought she was in distress so I drove my boyfriend over ( he has no drivers licenses). I had no ideal the cause of her distress was charges over her head to set someone up for the police to arrest and convict. Now my boyfriend turned states evidence and dropped the things he had on his person in my car and made a statement to the police that it was mine. I am in a postion where the police is threatening with 40-life unless I set up 3 or more people in controlled drug buys. I am trying to pay back $10,000 bond to my families members to be able to be free to take care of my kids. While his bond was $2,500, i bonded his out not knowing he lied and said the things in the car was mine. I have 5 children ages range from 16 years old to 7 months. I am well educated and am in school working on my bachlor degree in psychology. If i dont get some kind of answers I will be in jail or dead in a drug buy gone bad. I need to know my writes I have a public defender and they say its on me if I decide to go into the informants program or that the people they have been seeing in the same curcumstances with first offense have been getting 30 years in prison or more. I have been resourcing but law is not my field of study. Can I get some help here. This way of the police getting there job done has got to end. the worst people are still walking the streets while the people that have a chance to improve their lives and walk away are making their numbers for the year on convictions. I had a cousin that was shot 9 times in the stomach and rolled out of a car on the street. I can almost guarantee he has a snitch folder and was probably trying to get out of jail time when he was killed. I dont want to end up the same way and forgot about. you can contact me on my email. But my time is running short.